« Maus Assumption | Main | Spiegelman Makes Us Care »

Everyone Reacts Differently

"Pssh. Why always you want to buy when you can find!?"
~Vladek from Maus by Art Spiegelman, page 116.

In class the other day, we had a discussion about the importance of back stories. I still stick to what I said that they are important but not always completely necessary. I think this comic, however, is a good example of a case in which the back story is necessary in order to fully understand the significance of the vivid details.

Vladek is cheap. In the scene that the above quote is from he picked a wire up from the ground fully intending to use it. Artie doesn't fully understand why he doesn't just buy a wire, but he does figure that it has to do with his past--as he says later to Mala when she complains about how stingy he is. Though Artie doesn't bring this up in the same scene as the one this quote came from, the reader can, by this point, make this connection. Artie's defense to Mala merely reinforces what we already guessed. Vladek's need to find things and make the most of his money when in hiding is what conditioned him to be this way. Mala's argument is that she went through the same thing Vladek did, but she wasn't stingy. If Vladek's analysis of Mala is accurate and not an exaggeration, Mala would be his exact opposite. She doesn't want to have any financial restraint. She wants all of the luxuries that she was deprived of during the war.

These are two people who went through the same thing, yet they reacted to it in two completely different ways. I guess it goes to show that when dealing with situations like this, it is best not to try and fit everything into one nice little neat box. It simply doesn't work that way. Everyone reacts differently. Each case, therefore, must be handled and understood differently. It is best to simply be open minded, understanding, and supportive. Maybe this was one of the author's points in writing this story--in addition to the overall idea of making sure the story is told.

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://blogs.setonhill.edu/mt/mt-sp23oozye_tb.cgi/10899

Comments (3)

Just the way this novel is written shows how people have to react differently. This is a graphic novel - a huge difference from other reactions to the Holocaust. It is written like a comic, not a novel, not a poem, not a play, not a short story - so many different reactions all to the same event.

Everyone reacts differently: absolutely true. It is the same with many survivors of war. Some are so grateful to be alive, and they relish their freedom, allowing themselves all that they were deprived of. But, some still ,live in fear, not wanting to become accustomed to freedom, as it may be snatched away at any moment. Going along with this line of reasoning, I am reminded of my cousin Daria.
Daria was adopted when she was 5 or 6 from a poor Russian orphanage. She was very unaccustomed to having freedom. For months after the adoption, she was rigildy obedient, never stepping out of line. Daria never left anything on the floor or her bed unmade. She was too obidient, if there is such a thing. Her mother asked her why she was behaving liek this, and Daria said "because I am afraid i am going to be sent back there[orphanage]."

Something as horrible as the Holocuast will cause a profound reaction later on in life positively or negatively. I think by us seeing Vladek's affected more visually we can see what affect this will have in the story.

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)

About

This page contains a single entry from the blog posted on November 2, 2007 8:54 PM.

The previous post in this blog was Maus Assumption.

The next post in this blog is Spiegelman Makes Us Care.

Many more can be found on the main index page or by looking through the archives.