February 28, 2006

EL150: Cleopatra as Fortuna

Simonds, ""`To the Very Heart of Loss': Renaissance iconography in Shakespeare's Antony and Cleopatra."

Peggy Simonds reference of Cleopatra as representing the Roman goddess Fortuna fits extremely well with the themes of the play. Fortuna, the goddess of both good and bad luck, is a two-faced seductress who bends the wills of men into taking chances which (more often than not) end up being bad decisions. Simmonds commitment to this claim is astounding considering that she breaks up Fortuna's traits into nine categories, and gives examples (ranging from "okay" to "excellent") for reach one of them.

The strongest example she has is of Fortuna's two-faced persona. My classmates and I said many times both in class and on our blogs that Cleopatra was completely two-faced throughout the play. Half the time she was siding with Antony, telling him how much she loved him and wanted to be with him, and the other half she would sink into this extreme feeling of jealousy and betrayal. She supported Antony, up until she would retreat in battle. And just as Simond's says, Antony takes a risk in trusting her. "More recently," she says, "Michael Lloyd hints that Antony is addicted rather specifically to games of chance, which are mentioned over and over again in the play, and which increasingly cause him to become a pawn of the fickle goddess Fortuna."

After reading this article, I couldn't help but draw similar conclusions about Woody Allen's latest film Match Point, which is a story very similar to that of Antony and Cleopatra. The story revolves around the idea that luck drives every aspect of our lives, and the outcomes of our choices are only determined by chance. It's a story about a man who marries into an English upper class family, only to have an affair with an out-of-work American actress (played by Scarlett Johansson). She, like Cleopatra, is overtly sexual and two-faced. Johansson's character is the embodiment of Fortuna. The parallels between Match Point's aristocracy vs exotic American lower class is very similar to that of Rome vs Egypt. I know this class is Intro to Literary Study (and I keep shifting towards Film Study), I find it important to catch these intertextual references that bridge the gap between Renaissance mythology, Shakespearean tragedy, and modern day filmmaking.

Posted by MikeRubino at February 28, 2006 7:09 PM | TrackBack


Comments

Mike,
I like how you find similarities between different texts. It helps us to understand what the original text is about. These connections are great.

The one thing that you mentioned was what I really liked about the article. You talked about how Michael Lloyd hinting that "Antony is addicted rather specifically to games of chance, which are mentioned over and over again in the play, and which increasingly cause him to become a pawn of the fickle goddess Fortuna." I really liked this connection that Simmonds made with chance and fortune. To me, this whole play is about chance and how Antony is really a slave to chance. Other characters in the play such as Caesar make their own paths and get what they want through power. Since Antony is so "wishy-washy" he never let's himself get a chance (no pun intended) to stabilize and make decisions not based on chance, but based on strategy.

Posted by: Andy LoNigro at February 28, 2006 8:06 PM

And that, I think, is the big difference between relying on "strategy" and "chance." Antony relies on chance, and in the end he has little control over the events or his fate. He loses wars because of Cleopatra, and eventually he is left with no choice but to either live in shame or kill himself (and since this is a Shakespeare play, he kills himself.)

Caesar relies on strategy. He is constantly playing the angles, employing spies, and double crossing his allies. He is complete control, it seems, because he does not give in to Fortuna/Cleopatra's temptations. And in the end, Caesar is the victor.

Posted by: Mike Rubino at February 28, 2006 8:17 PM
Post a comment









Remember personal info?