I have read many opinions on this poem, and there is going to be one good discussion in class about this. After reading a lot of the comments, i am confused on my own view now. The one part of the poem goes
With my gypsy ancestress and my wierd luck
And my Taroc pack and my Taroc pack
I may be a bit like a Jew
During WWII the Germans tried to get rid of all the Jews and Gypsies. Both were seen as inferior to the German population. Many gyupsies were sent to concentration camps along with jews. According to http://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/jsource/Holocaust/gypsies.html
perhaps 250,000 gypsies were killed. In my opinion she did not kill her father, it seems to me that he was killed during the war. It seems that her mother had a fling with this guy and she was the product. Once the war started, he turned them in as being gypsies and didn't say anything. It states, "the villagers never liked you. . . they always knew it was you"
Scott, This poem is by far one of the more confusing ones to interpret. However, it helps to look at Plath's background and biography. If you want to see my view on "Daddy", take a look at my blog and let me know what you think. Plath was not a gypsy nor was she Jewish, but she was trying to make the comparison as a victim to her father, who was German. Her father died when she was young and I assume she tried to make him into a horrible person (like a Nazi) to let go of his memory. I am also looking forward to the class discussion on this one.
Posted by: Kayla Turano at March 2, 2005 8:09 PMScott, going by that definition, how would you explaing Plath's hatred for her father? There's definitely something going on here that we're having a tough time getting the hang of.
Posted by: Neha at March 2, 2005 10:49 PMseriously? Read her bio, then look at the poem less literally. She isn't just referring to her dead father but her husband and her mental illness. Plath is famous for using metaphor and this is one sugesting her isolation and herself as the victim.
Posted by: Amy at December 3, 2006 12:12 PMDear Scott,
Thank you so much for posting this article. I am doing a poetry explication in english over this poem and this posting helped me understand the poem better. Even though i am only in 10th grade i have seen the same thing as you in this poem. Again thanks.
--Laura
I think she hates her father for dying because she loved him so much when he was alive. Her husband is the vampire she tried to replace him with. There are also references to her mother, who was Austrian. Also, notice that she wrote this the day she got her divorce papers signed. Shortly after she committed suicide
Posted by: 12thGrader at October 22, 2007 5:17 PMI think Sylvia Plath is trying to show an 'oppressor-oppressed' relationship between her and her father by playing the role as a Jew and he a Nazi.
Posted by: Ana at January 8, 2008 7:17 PMgrr!! although your explanation is good, it would be better if you read her biography in order to fully understand the poem. She feels a strong resentment for her father who was not there for her when she needed him the most. She blames him (she does mention and repeat the word you throughout the poem) for the disaster her life turns out to be. This gives the poem an accusitive tone and mood since she does seem to be pointing a finger in his direction. Her life turns out to be a total screw up as well as her marriage. she let other people influence her life. knowing that she was deprived of a male influence in her life, she searched for a replacement, a model of her father, which she found in Ted. This poem is not only aimed at her fathe, but it is also aimed at Ted who sucked her blood for one year, seven to be more exact. her marriage lasted only seven years, but that one year refers to when Ted was having an affair with his mistress Assia Weville. when she mentions the telephone and the voices that couldnt worm through she is referring to the the phone conversation between Assia and Ted which she overheard. well watever
if would like to know more just email me
=)
bonbon.2009@hotmail.com
yvonne
Posted by: bonbon aka yvonne at January 11, 2008 5:38 PM