In "A Streetcar Named Desire" I observed glitches in the marriage between Stella and Stanley, which eventually led to the rape of Stella's sister Blanche by her husband Stanley. I decided to blog on abusive relationships and the growing numbers that come along with them. For some reason when I think of abuse, I register physical abuse right along with mental abuse. In this play, however I really only noticed physical abuse from Stanley. The abuse is not obvious at first. In fact, at the beginning of the play the marriage between Stanley and Stella seems almost blissful despite their less than luxurious living arrangements. The relationship is clearly very sexual and that connects the couple very strongly. But shortly after Blanche arrives, the violence becomes prevalent. Stanley, after drinking most of the evening, slaps Stella in the face because she was trying to get his poker friends to leave their two-bedroom apartment late at night.
After reading this section I thought to myself about not only abuse in marriages but rape and how it is addressed. Statistics on rape are enough to astound almost anyone. I do not mean to generalize and say that all people will be shocked by the statistics on this webpage but I thought it was fair enough to state that they are astoundingly high. Attesting to the growing number, these statistics were reported by the FBI, National Victim Center and Crime Victims Research and Treatment Center, U.S. Department of Justice Bureau of Justice Statistics, Crime and Crime Prevention Statistics along with an article for The Nursing Journal over 10 years ago so these numbers would presumably be inflated to an even higher level.
Violence in relationships is a growing problem along with drugs and obesity. This play helps to demonstrate that marital violence is not a new issue but it is growing in magnitude since the 1940's.
I've decided to edit this entry to disagree slightly with one of my peers opinions on this topic. Rebecca Villano's thoughts were of the nature that the abuse that Stella endured was a result of her own fault and his dislike of Blanche was also Stella's fault for not telling him she was coming sooner. In fact, I'm not even sure that Stella knew Blanche was coming, I didnt' think she was coming. I am of the mind that no matter what Stella did or didn't say or to do Stanley, nothing makes it her fault enough to abuse her the way Stanley did.
Posted by EmilyEvans at March 10, 2004 10:11 PMThose statistics are indeed shocking... but as always, beware of statistics that are assembled with the purpose of shocking you into action.
One statistic on the page you cited claims about 300,000 "forcible rapes" against women per year, which works out to about 820 a day and 34 an hour, or one every two minutes... indeed, that's shocking. Compare that to as another statistic on the same page, which says there is one "forcible rape" or "attempted rape" every five minutes. How can there be one forcible rape every two minutes, when another measure for both forcible rapes and attempted rapes is only one every five minutes? Something's wrong here.
I am not trying to downplay the seriousness of rape or the value of political action to stop sexual assault, but be careful about how you use statistics that you find on activist webpages -- no matter what the subject matter.
While sexual assault is a good topic to look at in this play, using a play from the 1940s and statistics from the 1990s isn't really enough to support your claims about a trend. Do we know for a fact that domestic violence is increasing, or are more victims coming forward to report themselves as victims? If so, we know that the *reports* of domestic violence are increasing, but it's plausible that the reports are increasing while at the same time, the numbers of victims are decreasing. (A book on the history of domestic violence might have a chapter on the 40s.)
Posted by: Dennis G. Jerz at March 11, 2004 09:44 AMthank you for the criticism Professor Jerz, but I have a slight problem. I just got back to my room and read your comment. I am supposed to present tonight and my blog isn't up to par. i just wanted to post this so if you see it you are aware before class. If you don't see this before class, i will just tell you there.
Posted by: Emily at March 11, 2004 05:35 PMrapes of extreme incest are wellcome.
Posted by: Real rape at October 6, 2004 07:19 AM