« EL 266 Foster (envoi)...In summary | Main | EL 266 Address of Booker T. Washington- Academia at night »

EL 266 John Henry The mighty force of manual labor

"John Henry was a railroad man,
He worked from six 'till five" (Ballad of John Henry)

I think that the ballad of John Henry was propaganda for late Nineteenth Century industrialization. After slavery was abolished in the late Nineteenth Century, as we know from history, industrialization boomed. This brought jobs to America and a dream. I feel that the legend of John Henry is all about the American dream.
Giving the mythological character super-human like qualities in my opinion was a sales pitch for the United States. Basically saying that America is tough. It is built on hard work, sweat, and muscle. That is the framework for our country.
Take for instance, Pittsburgh. Our beloved city. It was built on steel and iron. In the late 1960s-1970s, the industry progressed at such a high rate. This employed many people. Steel and iron were icons for the local sport's teams. Making their mascots reflect the thriving ores.
Of course it's a tall tale.The story of the ballad could have never happened. That just seems to far-fetched. I feel it was more symbolic than anything.
As far as the different versions of the song. They are, in my opinion, coming from different perspectives. Who originally wrote the song? As I took a look at all the different songwriters who mention John Henry, I see that white men (Bruce Springsteen and Johnny Cash) they were well known for songs about America and the hardships to be endured. But a blues singer like Led Belly sang about blacks and the hardships they endured. Overall, I feel that the ballad describes overcoming hardships entering the American dream.
I really do not see racism as an issue in John Henry.


I agreee. I do not the poem as a means for addressing racism at all.

I like that you put John Henry into the perspective of "overcoming the hardships entering the American dream". I can definitely see that translation of the poem. The first thing I had thought of the poem was that it showed John Henry as a hardworking man who was dedicated to his job and that ties exactly into what I was thinking.

I definitely agree that his story describes the hardships entering into the American Dream, but I think racism does play a part in it as well. These men were legally freed not too long ago if I understand correctly. Also, as soon as these men were freed from bondage of the white men, machines quickly enslaved them. There was no free transition period before they were forced into the American Dream.

I agree that the story describes the hardships of America and entering America. I didn't see the idea of racism in the songs at all. They had to fight for their jobs and survival in America and John Henry was trying to prove that through his hard work and attempt at beating the steam drill.

I do agree with most of what you say Jeremy. While I can definitely see John Henry as propaganda, I also think it was based on some true facts. I mean, there were probably many newly freed slaves working on the rail road at this time. I don't think it is propaganda, because manual labor may have been the only thing that was available to the freedmen for work.

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)

[Future Spam Check]